Tumma

This is why we can't have nice things 

Veritasium
Tilaa 9 milj.
Näkymät 5 milj.
99% 52 227 466

This video is about stuff: light bulbs, printers, phones and why they aren't better. Go to NordVPN.com/veritasium and use code VERITASIUM to get a 2-year plan plus 1 additional month with a huge discount. It’s risk free with Nord’s 30 day money-back guarantee!
References:
The Man in the White Suit - ve42.co/Suit
London, B. (1932). Ending the depression through planned obsolescence. - ve42.co/London32
Slade, G. (2009). Made to break: Technology and obsolescence in America. Harvard University Press - ve42.co/madetobreak
Krajewski, M. (2014). The great lightbulb conspiracy. IEEE spectrum, 51(10), 56-61. - ve42.co/Phoebus
Planet Money, The Phoebus Cartel - ve42.co/PMobs
The Light Bulb Conspiracy - fiplace.info/loft/videot/nnCrnZ9ok26rgWk
Special thanks to Patreon supporters: Mac Malkawi, Oleksii Leonov, Michael Schneider, Jim Osmun, Tyson McDowell, Ludovic Robillard, jim buckmaster, fanime96, Juan Benet, Ruslan Khroma, Robert Blum, Richard Sundvall, Lee Redden, Vincent, Lyvann Ferrusca, Alfred Wallace, Arjun Chakroborty, Joar Wandborg, Clayton Greenwell, Pindex, Michael Krugman, Cy 'kkm' K'Nelson, Sam Lutfi, Ron Neal
Written by Derek Muller and Petr Lebedev
Animation by Ivan Tello
Filmed by Derek Muller and Raquel Nuno
Edited by Derek Muller
Video supplied by Getty Images
Music by Jonny Hyman and from epidemicsound.com"Aquatic Planet", "Rhythm of Dreams", "Tread Lightly", "Unexpected Visitors", "Curved Mirrors" "Drunken Lullaby" "Fluorescent Lights"
Thumbnail by Raquel Nuno and Karri Denise

Julkaistu

 

26.03.2021

Jaa:

Jaa:

Ladata:

Ladataan.....

Lisää soittolistaan:

Oma soittolista
Katso myöhemmin
Kommentteja 100   
Macgyver Siruma
Macgyver Siruma 2 tuntia sitten
thats why spark plug this day has a resistor.
The Executed Code
The Executed Code 2 tuntia sitten
Is this enough for you stupid iPhone users?
sashidemedia
sashidemedia 2 tuntia sitten
So if this video doesn't convince you. Apple is a product for sheeple. Idiots buy apple products. Smart people buy their stock
Technical Extreme
Technical Extreme 3 tuntia sitten
This episode came many times in my in my Home Tab. But I was reluctant to click it because I was afraid of getting bored. I was wrong. One of the best videos on FIplace.
Anything Mike
Anything Mike 3 tuntia sitten
Right to repair.
Temp Bauer
Temp Bauer 3 tuntia sitten
I don’t mind new colors or styles or design that make the person WANT the new version but things that don’t work as well and/or break that force consumer to NEED to buy new is bs
Temp Bauer
Temp Bauer 3 tuntia sitten
Intentional planned obsolescence! The lite bulb ppl were the original masters of marketing/sales, the original gangsta biz men!
Mr Bardel
Mr Bardel 3 tuntia sitten
capitalism need things to break ... cancer capitalism must die ...
sharfaz hameed
sharfaz hameed 3 tuntia sitten
Great information. But honestly the way Elon Musk thinks very different n making life more convenient for people unlike these light bulb companies n imagine these idiotic authorizes making fine or penalty for making a good bulb.
David Lucey
David Lucey 4 tuntia sitten
They are out to get you. Don’t get me started on big Pharma
Sarah
Sarah 4 tuntia sitten
basically profit incentive and capitalism...it would be better for the environment if things like this lasted longer....I'm so disgusted at this
The Goldey Family
The Goldey Family 4 tuntia sitten
RIGHT TO REPAIR!!!
Wesley Andrew
Wesley Andrew 4 tuntia sitten
I liked it. but 3.5k dislikes ? why ? can there be so many accidental clicks ?
Ankit Shaw
Ankit Shaw 4 tuntia sitten
I purchased a light bulb two days ago and it lasted 24 hours....
Law Rence
Law Rence 4 tuntia sitten
"But there are no conspiricies ... you are a nuthead if you believe there would be some people conspiring against other people ... no no, rich man only want the best for us"
Bhavik Yadav
Bhavik Yadav 5 tuntia sitten
Please tell your friend Michael Stevens to be as consistent as you. We long for his content Amazing video btw
Arun Vignesh
Arun Vignesh 5 tuntia sitten
Oooooh. This debunking is painful for both businesses owners and customers alike.
Simon Hawkins
Simon Hawkins 6 tuntia sitten
But now they put fewer LED modules on a bulb so they get hotter and die sooner....
Game Pirate
Game Pirate 6 tuntia sitten
I love this channel more than Vsauce. You present many original ideas in original ways.
BRIAN WILSON
BRIAN WILSON 6 tuntia sitten
Every expensive long life, environmentally bulb I've bought has lasted a max of 6 months.
Campbell Tate
Campbell Tate 6 tuntia sitten
You want to talk about conspiracies, how about the fact that Exxon and Shell researched and correctly predicted global warming as early as the 80s, and then proceeded to cover it up? Also, anything to do with US foreign policy in just about any country in Central or South America
Артем Коничек
So why we can't have nice things? I think, this video clearly shows us that we don't deserve it! At least in a modern state of mind. We create our future by our own hands and minds. In russian language one can say "Не нравится? Голосуй кошельком!" which means, in a long run, its always better for you to not buy and support stuff that bends you over.
Артем Коничек
Oh, TIL: there is english idiom "Voting with your wallet" with the same meaning. Didn't know that
elizabeth green
elizabeth green 7 tuntia sitten
Show this in schools!
Swordmaster Sam
Swordmaster Sam 7 tuntia sitten
I like the everlasting LED bulb, except I have a problem with it: the intensity and color. That bright white is very harsh compared to the soft orange of more traditional bulbs.
Kakwann
Kakwann 7 tuntia sitten
LEDs have started to get worse for the same reason you mentioned. also i saw a video of some Philipps in Dubai. They have to make them more efficient for certain market. Basically, their lightbulb was using 2 time less power and was as bright as the american model. making it lasting longer also. but the product is not available to other markets because "Philipps".
GyanAddict
GyanAddict 8 tuntia sitten
And also, your phone and other devices are always tracked. No matter if you turn off your GPS, or even turn off your phone. You're always being watched. It's your permanent record.
kvasp0urmom
kvasp0urmom 9 tuntia sitten
You are a GOD. Thank you for your videos
Gumbar Limbits
Gumbar Limbits 9 tuntia sitten
CaPiTaLIsM Is EfFicIeNt
Cynthia Allaire
Cynthia Allaire 9 tuntia sitten
One large conspiracy is that you were persuaded by Operation Mockingbird and Bill Gates associate Dr. Fauci that two masks were protective while you were outside away from everyone but your camera person. Conventional masks are more likely to damage your health unless your sanding or trying to filter out smoke or dust.
SixLeafCloverOFire
SixLeafCloverOFire 10 tuntia sitten
That light reminds me of the bubble in Spongebob that was over a million years old.
Steven Kitajima
Steven Kitajima 10 tuntia sitten
It's always about money. Any product you get, the company with ruin it just so you can buy their newest and more expensive product. Look at cars, and phones today
LaCuchiTromba
LaCuchiTromba 11 tuntia sitten
I don't know how to say this without sound like a pesimistic killjoy, but I have to replace my LED bulbs every year or less.
Jez
Jez 11 tuntia sitten
This is a great video, but the thumbnail i think is very misleading. I refused to watch this video for awhile because the thumbnail gave me the impression that this was merely about making fun of conspiracy theories.
Joseph Bowden
Joseph Bowden 11 tuntia sitten
The 3.7k dislikes are from the lightbulb companies.
AussieTV
AussieTV 11 tuntia sitten
I still have a radio from 1979 that still works perfectly. Might be just lucky.
PJV1990
PJV1990 12 tuntia sitten
To everyone watching this video (and reading this comment) PLEASE support right to repair. Contact your local politician, spread the word online and get as many other people as possible to support the right to repair movement. This closed system policy (no third party repairs, only allowing 'genuine' parts and tech components soldered in place) with outrageously expensive 'repairs' (that are not repairs, all they do is swap your product for a new one) cannot be allowed to continue. The current system literally treats you like a fool and nothing more than a bag of money to keep the profit machine churning. All the major tech companies do it such as Apple, Samsung, Google etc.. However with the rise of the electric vehicle, car manufacturers are starting to pull the same s**t (I'm looking at you Tesla). So I BEG you, please support Right To Repair and spread the word/get as many other people to support it too. Lobby your local, state/county and national politicians until they are forced to act and support Right To Repair. If we don't act now and keep the momentum going then we'll just turn into slaves and walking wallets for the big tech and automotive companies.
Madhu Sridharan
Madhu Sridharan 12 tuntia sitten
Hey, what if man is the 'Planned obsolescence' of God?
Predrag-Peter Ilich
Predrag-Peter Ilich 13 tuntia sitten
LED - an "everlasting light bulb"! My casual, unbiased observation is that the newest LEDs last shorter than the ones bought, say 10-15 years ago. Where have I bought LED light bulbs the last 2 years? USA, PR China, and mid Europe.
Duke
Duke 13 tuntia sitten
This crap is still going on with LED bulbs..... Look into the Dubai LED bulbs from Phillips. You are not allowed to buy them anywhere else. They run on a quarter of the LEDs rated power and have awesome chips so that they can take the heat. It was due to their regulations in Dubai and Phillips stood up to meet the challenge with the understanding they had sole ownership. Of course Phillips wont sell them to the rest of the world for fear their sales will plummet in years to come.
Felix JN
Felix JN 13 tuntia sitten
Thank you! You have a lot of good episodes, but this is one of my favourite so far!
El White Boy
El White Boy 13 tuntia sitten
Planned obsolescence.
Deans n LiPo
Deans n LiPo 14 tuntia sitten
I have changed all the LEDs in my house a little less often than I would incandescent bulbs. The power supply is what wears out so I think light bulbs are still following the old model.
LaGodny
LaGodny 14 tuntia sitten
Last year I bought 100 LED light bulbs for church and they supposed to last 25 years but unfortunately all of them already burned after one year. Some of them burned in one month and one by one they all burned so manufacturers laying to us and stilling our money. They are criminals.
nick mccurdie
nick mccurdie 14 tuntia sitten
Well light bulbs are only “meant” to last such a short time so the companies making them make money, and electricity companies don’t have to come out and say that electricity could be free and used forever without any limit on usage.
Anthony Yaoyang.T
Anthony Yaoyang.T 14 tuntia sitten
Capitalism at its finest
Redhoney sugarOrange
Redhoney sugarOrange 14 tuntia sitten
Reminds me of the movie robots
Eduardo .Monares
Eduardo .Monares 14 tuntia sitten
Nice.
Tisha Arboleda
Tisha Arboleda 14 tuntia sitten
In the early 20th century, Filipino electrician Agapito Flores invented the fluorescent lamp, which was allegedly named after himself.
Andy MacNicol
Andy MacNicol 15 tuntia sitten
This episode is awesome
D
D 15 tuntia sitten
dirty cartel bastards
LampDoesVideogame
LampDoesVideogame 15 tuntia sitten
Pssst. The entirety of QI is posted on YT @QI TV Show
Motri
Motri 15 tuntia sitten
Well,led light bulbs are just worst then every other bulbs. No mater what company or quality. If it doesnt break it just loses light. In one year or so you end up with almost have the light...
Cocoa
Cocoa 15 tuntia sitten
"Capitalism promotes innovation." The capitalism practice in question:
Pedro147
Pedro147 16 tuntia sitten
This light bulb cartel was the beginning of designed obselecance
Michael Smith
Michael Smith 16 tuntia sitten
I bought a washer, dryer, refrigerator and stove in 1982 when I bought my new house for 47K. I just replaced my washer this year 2021. My car is a 1997 Mazda b 2200 purchased new in 1997 and I still have that. Believe me I know about planned obsolescence. I stay away from Chinese products as much as possible, they don't last and are a great threat to America.I watched in 2020 as my wife had to retire early because of the CCP Flu and planned global gov. Amazon and Walmart got very wealthy as was planned, I won't buy from either of them. As consumers I have found I don't need a new wizit every year, I don't need one and it really doesn't make this old fossil any happier. I have however gotten more PO'ed as time goes by watching these global bastards screw every one around.
John Mcmillan
John Mcmillan 16 tuntia sitten
I had the "built to break" thing figured out before I was 10, What rock have you been under?
Ashish Tyagi
Ashish Tyagi 16 tuntia sitten
They live
Jaden Potts
Jaden Potts 16 tuntia sitten
this is an interesting arugument against capitalism
Anarchy Antz
Anarchy Antz 17 tuntia sitten
LED bulbs are NOT everlasting at all, that is a lie. I have had to replace 7 of the things in the last couple of years and they are not cheap. Have a three bulb fitting, one went, a week later the next followed by the third and all brought at the same time and not even run all the time. Thing is with this "right to repair" is you will get all these home users trying it, injuring themselves then blaming and suing the manufactures when it goes tits up. Or your car could have all its data collected as per American adverts showing it being done, same for phones and laptops. Look at cases where your data has ended up in the news because someone leaked it to the press when your device went in for repair with these third party people. They should be given to the proper people. And I wouldnt trust someone sponsored by NORD VPN who failed to tell their users for 18 months when they were hacked and had a massive data breach.
wishbones
wishbones 17 tuntia sitten
I’ll start the bid for the nft of that lightbulb for 20 million. Someone will say one day.
Silkworm
Silkworm 17 tuntia sitten
I'd argue your point at the end was incorrect and ironic since yiu opened with an original light bulb that supposedly has been on continuous for over a hundred years. No LED light bulb (except in theory) has that lifespan. Also I can almost be certain the socket will have changed in 100 years
Hawk Volante
Hawk Volante 17 tuntia sitten
It's not just light bulbs everything is made to break so we the consumer has to buy pretty much everything in our homes, even our cars. If everything was made to last forever, companies would go broke and they can't let that happen thanks to greed!
Neuronaut Alpha-1
Neuronaut Alpha-1 17 tuntia sitten
Oh, if you say so. As long as someone can tell me what's what. Cuz, u know I can't make up my own mind. Get a life.
J.E. B.
J.E. B. 18 tuntia sitten
Anyone else on here to say you've bought LED bulbs that haven't lasted very long?
2to2
2to2 18 tuntia sitten
LED light commercial...
jubuttib
jubuttib 18 tuntia sitten
Waiting for someone to actually make a socketable LED bulb that reliably lasts for significantly longer than compact fluorescent ones. I at least have had very bad luck with mine (been using bulbs from Philips, Airam, Osram, Ikea, and some other random lesser known ones). I don't think it's necessarily the diodes that keep breaking, from what I can tell the problem is mainly the power supply portion. An LED can't run on your normal AC power from the wall, it needs a small power supply unit to get the kind of electricity it needs. And apparently building this into the base/stem of a pretty small bulb light isn't trivial, and can lead to longevity issues. The longest running LED "bulb" I have is a 2000 lumen one that specifically has a big finned metal base to help keep the PSU portion cool, that has been running for years and years now. And a couple of low power ones, which don't really seem to warm up. My 600-1200 lumen bulbs, which I'd prefer to use for general lighting though, those get really hot at the base, and don't seem to last too long.
Chris Bartos
Chris Bartos 18 tuntia sitten
Dude. this channel is INCREDIBLE AF!
jubuttib
jubuttib 18 tuntia sitten
Great video overall, but I'm sad to see the "Ford Model T was only available in black" myth perpetuated. It was always available in various colors, and black wasn't even an option until many years into the production. "A common myth is that all model T’s were black. While Henry Ford did say “Any customer can have a car painted any color that he wants so long as it’s black,” the policy was in place solely for efficiency and uniformity. The car was only offered in black from 1914-1925, however before and after that various models of the vehicle could be purchased in a variety of colors including blue, red, grey, and green."
Abhinav Sharma
Abhinav Sharma 18 tuntia sitten
Apple has been making a fool of everyone, but the fact is there is no perfect fool. Just a different one every season.
CJWarlock
CJWarlock 18 tuntia sitten
So, basically, these industry tycoons were not creative enough and not ambitious enough to create next business after the former one had lost its usefulness, therefore they stuck to viciously addicting their customers to insanely short-lasting products. And the society pays the environmental costs with short-lasting health. ;)
Silkworm
Silkworm 19 tuntia sitten
This is the reason a lot of us stopped using Apple products years ago.
wreckcelsior
wreckcelsior 19 tuntia sitten
Planned obsolescence... makes me think of robots. cheers.
Lucky Auto
Lucky Auto 19 tuntia sitten
and this is why we have global warming and pollution. where is tesla and his limitless energy? Cars used to be better, and now everything is manufactured to be used for a while and broken. filling up landfills and our oceans dying.
Zap Gun
Zap Gun 19 tuntia sitten
For a sponsored video, one that's only 17 and a half minutes long no less, this has got an awful lot of advertisements in it. Bit disappointed.
daniel kinney
daniel kinney 19 tuntia sitten
i ordered Nord VPN off your videos. Works awesome glad i got it for my entire Apple 2 Mac Book Pro's & iMac 2 iPhones & iPad
Diksaca Yehovah
Diksaca Yehovah 19 tuntia sitten
The same corporate consciousness trying to control every aspect of human life through the political vehicle known as muh "climate change" but is really Agenda 21 is the same consciousness behind the planned obsolescence that violates the earth of resources to make stuff that ends up in a landfill. So illuminati so enlightened these maya mon.keys of Clown-Yuga.
antlerr
antlerr 19 tuntia sitten
something soo small as a lightbulb made to break yet is possible to have need of only one lightbulb forever....... misses the huge picture if they did that to a light something so small what else could be only need of one yet forced to have crap huh??????? pick a object anyone! so you and everyone else miss the huge picture and still are dumb sheep lead to slaughter.
Diksaca Yehovah
Diksaca Yehovah 19 tuntia sitten
capitalism devolves into cartel syndicates. The entire planet is run by cartels. From central banking cartels (Rothschild, Oppenheimer, Warburg, Schiff) all the way down to the lowest common denominator.
Diksaca Yehovah
Diksaca Yehovah 19 tuntia sitten
Dat capitalism Clown-Yuga burden tho
daniel kinney
daniel kinney 19 tuntia sitten
I just want to marry you.
Johann Gambolputty
Johann Gambolputty 20 tuntia sitten
Thanks for covering this in so much detail!
FigJam963
FigJam963 21 tunti sitten
That last statement relies on the component it's built with, some cheap bulbs have cheap LEDs that burn out, and just like the old Christmas lights, one bulbs burnt out, they all go, unless you can Crack it open and bypass the burnt out LED...
DIY Dave
DIY Dave 21 tunti sitten
But we are already seeing the reality of the false flag of years-long LED bulbs. Yes, the LED itself lasts nearly indefinitely as a practical matter, but they are being packaged into garbage components with cheap (well, crappy) power supplies, cheap capacitors, and dodgy circuitry - all of which are proving to fail almost as frequently as the old incandescent bulbs they were destined to replace. So I've already changed several LED bulbs - three just in the last week, ironically enough - and my house is twenty years old. So we're not *quite* to that sell-my-house-before-changing-a-bulb nirvana just yet.
Random Things _official channel_
ᗩᗯEᔕOᗰE ᐯIᗪEO
Ismail Vaseer
Ismail Vaseer 21 tunti sitten
please make channel name easy i cant pronounce the name when i try to suggest someone.
Ismail Vaseer
Ismail Vaseer 21 tunti sitten
i knew that becuase i lived in pakistan and we use Chinese products which break after using few days
Random Things _official channel_
Planned obsolescence can also be said about the evolution of jeans trends As ripped and torn jeans became the latest fashion and was more costlier than the ordinary jeans. Now beggers Even Seems to be in the latest trends
sachin singh
sachin singh 21 tunti sitten
Okay, so this video was showing in my youtube feed repeatedly. I was avoiding this video because of its length. Finally out of frustration I clicked on the video found it very informative. Thanks
Night Fury
Night Fury 21 tunti sitten
very captivating video
acolytetojippity
acolytetojippity 22 tuntia sitten
the original Model Ts were not available in Black. The paint became an eventual bottleneck in the manufacturing process, having to wait for it to dry was taking too much time. A new paint came out that was fast-drying but it was only available in black.
Andy Green
Andy Green 22 tuntia sitten
Turns out Corporate Conspiracies have been keeping technology back on purpose so they can sell more inefficient bulbs! Take a guess what other industries have been doing this... Ahem Big Pharma Perhaps it is Time we the People fine these companies for holding humanity back & furthering unnecessary pollution. Perhaps We The People need to take back what is Ours & hold these crooks responsible for their crimes against humanity.
IkkySubmits
IkkySubmits 22 tuntia sitten
I never knew repairing something is a right
Dogaru Alexandru-Stefan
Dogaru Alexandru-Stefan 22 tuntia sitten
We need a resource based economy. Like the one advocated by The Venus Project
John C
John C 22 tuntia sitten
Back to lightbulbs, I now only buy LED ones. Whenever the incandescent ones die, I replace them with LED and I've yet to replace one of those.
John C
John C 22 tuntia sitten
By the way, as far as Apple, I don't have any of their products. Why? They're simply too expensive compared to other brands. I once had an iPod Touch that just kept getting slower and slower. Now, my regular phone does everything that device could do. So, I never bought another iPod. I remember that I originally bought it for $200. My cell-phone is far cheaper than that and far more useful. Also, Apple products aren't typically compatible with a lot of other products.
Samual Sisk
Samual Sisk 22 tuntia sitten
Seems like capitalism is prohibiting innovation.
Lost Puppy
Lost Puppy 23 tuntia sitten
Still going on even with anti trust laws. Now common practice actually for many industries. This is not surprising. Ty for the info.
John C
John C 23 tuntia sitten
My only problem with all this is when government gets involved. I'm a strong supporter of a total free market. But, the way I handle this is still the same. I seek the best value at the lowest prices. In this case, "best value" now means longest-lasting. Most batteries are marketed like that; Energizer is one example. I seek the longest-lasting vehicles, which are typically older Toyotas. I have a 1999 Camry and 2011 Tundra. The Camry will probably last longer. I have a Lenovo Thinkpad laptop that I bought used and has yet to have any problems. If this ever does die, I'm still not buying a new laptop. See, one thing that companies need to remember if they consider designing products to eventually be obsolete is that this hurts their reputation. If we go back to lightbulbs, I realize that I never even consider the brand. I always look for the ones that last the longest. If they still had a cartel pact to limit longevity, then the one that is just a little longer-lasting is still more competitive. Therefore, there's still incentive for companies to break the pact and for outside companies to also produce longer-lasting equivalents given newer, more developed technologies. As far as employment, such developments simply means the job market being shifted a bit towards a different area. One product might become virtually indefinite, as far as lifespan. But, there is still plenty of work to be done in other products. And, there are always new products to be designed, built, and developed to meet new consumer demand. In the late 1800's, automobiles became a new market. Then, aircraft did the same. Spacecraft are currently at a similar onset. Computers were once nonexistent. Now, everyone has them. What previously nonexistent technology may arise in the near future is virtually anyone's guess.
The_3lue_Gamer
The_3lue_Gamer 23 tuntia sitten
Another great video thank you again
hokiturmix
hokiturmix 23 tuntia sitten
Old Spice and the HDD are the all time best ever inventions. ... and ofc the hammer and the nail.
Seuraava
The Secret of Synchronization
20:58
Is Success Luck or Hard Work?
12:04
The Discovery That Transformed Pi
18:40
Polo G - RAPSTAR (Official Video)
2:49